WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. â As part of a content caper dreamed up by members of the Cardinalsâ social media crew, they enlisted the help of Topps and mostly the mothers and wives of players to surprise players with a boyish twist on their baseball cards.
On photo day this spring, a dozen Cardinals players, from Victor Scott II to Masyn Winn, were handed an actual 2025 Topps baseball card, but most of them had the usual action photo replaced with one of them as a kid. Michael Sianiâs featured him as a baby with a bat.
Thomas Saggese showed him wearing the birds on the bat.
âIt was a how-did-you-get-this kind of thing,â he said. âFunny.â
There he was in the photo, at 9, in the Carlsbad Youth Baseball league and playing for the Cardinals, and he was holding it, at 22, in spring training to play for the Cardinals.
âPretty wild,â he laughed.
At the point of the roster where the downstream impact of Nolan Arenado remaining with the Cardinals meets decisions through a longer-term lens balances, like a bird on a bat, Saggese. The reigning Texas League MVP a year ago in his first big-league camp, Saggese has spent this camp with an opportunity to be on the big-league roster, though the role available to him has shifted. There was a chance he could be a regular starter moving around the field to spell others, but with so many positions spoken for, the most obvious opening is on the bench.
That informs any conversation about Saggese with the classic prospect question of how playing sporadically in the majors compares to playing daily at Class AAA Memphis.
âWhat we have to consider in when weâre looking at bringing that extra guy is does it make sense to be someone like him,â manager Oliver Marmol said. âOr, does he need playing time if heâs not going to get a certain amount of at-bats a week.â
Marmol lauded Saggeseâs ability to work an at-bat, make contact with pitches throughout the zone, and do âwhatever is asked.â Marmol called him âa gamer.â
He did not have to wait long for another example.
In the second inning of the Cardinalsâ 5-3 victory against Washington on Saturday, Saggese persisted through a 10-pitch at-bat before finishing it with a single. Saggese fell behind 0-1, ignored a ball away for 1-1, and then fouled off six of the next seven pitches. Whatever Nationals lefty D.J. Herz tried to do, Saggese met it until he got a pitch over too much of the plate and pulled it to left field for a single. Saggese would score on a sacrifice fly to break a 1-1 tie.
âI donât think he can beat me with anything,â Saggese explained later. âLetâs stay on the heater. Thatâs the only thing. As long as I stay on the fastball, there is not a lot they have that can really get me out.â

Thomas Saggeseâs baseball card from a set the Cardinals and Topps made for a social media promotion. Each card features a photo from the Cardinalsâ youth, and in Saggeseâs card heâs in youth league, age 9 or 10, and heâs playing for the Cardinals. The team conspired with family members and Topps to surprise the players with the Cardinals on photo day.
Saggese followed with an infield single in the fourth off Herz and another run.
Heâs tied for the team lead in hits this spring. But if the Cardinals are leaning into their âtransitionâ or âreset,â his future as a starting infielder may be more valuable than his present off the bench to take that gritty, productive at-bat only five or six times a week.
It can be counterintuitive this notion that the better a young player plays in spring training and the higher his ceiling, the more likely it becomes if there isnât a clear position that he heads to Triple-A.
Marmol pushed back on that framing.
âI donât think itâs the better they play as much as where they are in their career, right?â Marmol said. âIf you have a guy who is young and promising only getting five, six at-bats a week then itâs less to do with how well they play. Just the bigger picture there.â
The travel team for Saturdayâs exhibition at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches had a distinct bench-battle vibe to it.
In addition to Saggese, as many as five other players in the starting lineup are jockeying to varying degrees for a backup spot on the opening day roster. And that group did not include Saturdayâs catcher Pedro Pages, who will split time or back up Ivan Herrera. Nor did it include top prospect JJ Wetherholt, who the manager has said he wants to play as often as possible before he moves to minor-league camp.
A seventh player in the derby because of his athleticism and defensive versatility, Jose Barrero, appeared as a replacement at shortstop later in the game.
Early game and on the road the day after the first Friday night lights game of spring of the chance to see the contenders âcompeting all together,â the manager said.
Following Saggese in the lineup were outfielders Matt Koperniak and Ryan Vilade. Koperniak has a knack for contact and comfort in both corner outfield spots. Between Koperniak and Vilade, out in center was Siani, the incumbent at his position but also in a contest for playing time and role if the Cardinals shift their outfield alignment. Luken Baker started at DH, and a strong spring with a team-high three homers has him shoving to be the right-handed bat off the bench.
If versatility guides the choice, there is Michael Helman, a steady fielder at multiple positions who the Cardinals acquired from Minnesota at the start of camp.
He hit ninth, speared a liner at second Saturday.
âVersatility is what we would want,â Marmol said when asked what heâd prefer in the 26th spot on the roster. âThe ability to play anywhere in the infield, pop out to the outfield, possibly.â
Saggese has spent most of his spring bouncing between third and second. He made his fifth start at third base on Saturday. There has been some discussion about getting Saggese some innings in the outfield, but no rush to do that. Marmol said the young infielder has the âpersonality and the skillsetâ to be the versatile player off the bench, often drawing comparisons to how Brendan Donovan arrived and thrived in the majors.
Where Saggese is aiming to improve is closer to another teammate, Alec Burleson. Acquired from Texas in the Jordan Montgomery trade in 2023, Saggese finished that season batting .306 with a .530 slugging percentage at three different levels. He gave the Texas League some time to catch up and no one did as he cinched the MVP with a .331 average and a 1.064 OPS in 33 games there with the Cardinalsâ Class AA affiliate. He played 18 games in the majors this past year and then continued his season with 18 more games at the invitation-only Arizona Fall League.
Saggese has a gift like Burleson for covering the strike zone, and itâs one of the comforts he has when falling behind in a count and facing a lefty like Herz. He can connect with any pitch, so never feels out of the at-bat.
What the Cardinals want Saggese to do is be more selective with his swings and, like Burleson, look for pitches that he can drive, not just reach.
âThat comes with reps,â he said. âI felt like I did a good job of that in the Fall League. It kind of clicked for me there â laying off pitches. I feel everybody talks about that, but I feel like I previously havenât had the reps. You need to see it over and over and over and again, and then I think you get better at laying off pitches.â
Reps.
At-bats.
Like the ones that are limited in a bench role.
Thatâs the calculus coming the Cardinals way on whether the boy with the birds on the bat starts his season with that same look, or is ready when that same jersey awaits in the season. This is the first spring when he can shape that choice, but the Cardinalsâ direction will make it.
âThe only thing that would be different is added pressure,â Saggese said. âI donât really feel that. I enjoy the game. Whatever happens, itâs not in my hands anyway. ⊠You always want to help the big-league club. You always want to be in the big leagues, regardless. Thatâs my only thought on that.â